Skeptical Raptor's Blog hunting pseudoscience in the internet jungle

How can homeopathy help to stop the Ebola outbreak?

homeopathy-waterIn case you’re assuming that it can, it really can’t.

Since any reasonable person would understand that homeopathy violates some of the basic principles of physics, chemistry and biology. And because there is no viable mechanism that would make you think homeopathy actually could work, clinical trials show that it doesn’t work, or, at best, it is a mythical placebo. So, if it doesn’t work in clinical trials, and there is no possible mechanism underlying it, employing Occam’s Razor, we would have to say the simplest explanation is the best: Homeopathy does not work. It’s a lie. It’s a scam. Period. End of story.

The current outbreak of the Ebola virus in West Africa has been making significant headlines lately. The virus is deadly, with a mortality rate well over 90%, easily transmitted by any bodily fluid, and there is no known cure. The course of the disease is horrifying, starting with symptoms similar to a bad flu, but eventually leading to blood clotting problems, failing organs like the kidney and liver, then finally death. The disease is not selective about whom it attacks, young or old, healthy or not.

Early treatment may increase the survival chance, since there is no known cure. Treatment focuses on replenishing fluids, maintaining proper blood pressure, replacing lost blood, and treating related infections.

And there is no vaccine to prevent the virus from infecting individuals. This isn’t a massive conspiracy to prevent a new vaccine from coming to the market. Developing the vaccine has been incredibly difficult because traditional vaccine development strategies, such as inactivation, have not been successful. In fact, several vaccines have shown to be successful in preventing Ebola infection in animals and non-human primates, but as I’ve said many times, success in animals only rarely translates to success in humans. Those vaccines that have shown promise are now undergoing substantial clinical trials, but human clinical trials for vaccines are complex and take time. In fact, there might Ebola vaccines available in the next few months.

Of course, the lack of a cure or prevention for Ebola means the anti-science quack pushers are out in force. And that means homeopaths.

One of these deranged homeopaths even suggested a treatment:

Dr. Gail Derin studied the symptoms of Ebola Zaire, the most deadly of the three that can infect human beings. Dr. Vickie Menear, M.D. and homeopath, found that the remedy that most closely fit the symptoms of the 1914 “flu” virus, Crolatus horridus, also fits the Ebola virus nearly 95% symptom-wise! Thanks go to these doctors for coming up with the following remedies:

1. Crolatus horridus (rattlesnake venom) 2. Bothrops (yellow viper) 3. Lachesis (bushmaster snake) 4. Phosphorus 5. Mercurius Corrosivus

ebola-virus-diseaseYes, three snake venoms. Ebola is dangerous, but I’m not sure getting venom from snakes is a risk I’m willing to take, even if all of this pseudoscience actually worked. Oh, and the irony of “Mercurius Corrosivus”, which is nothing more than mercuric chloride. Yes, mercury. My irony meter just blew up.

These pseudoscience pushing nutjobs even have their own “peer-reviewed journals” (by peer-reviewed, we mean other homeopaths reviewing each other for the quality of their pseudoscience), one of which describes a dilution with a ground up crustacean. Seriously, these people live in a world that somehow passed over the last 200 years of real science. Medieval alchemists have more credibility.

But let’s back up a bit, and explain the “science” of homeopathy, because a lot of people, mostly Americans, conflate homeopathy with natural medicine, like herbal medicine. It isn’t. Basically, homeopathy, known as the “law of similars”, relies on belief that “let like be cured by like”, and is a term coined by Samuel Hahnemann, a German physician who was appalled by the state of medicine at the time, the late 1700’s. And frankly, the state of medicine at that time was pretty bad, so any new idea might have been worthy of trying. However, when Hanneman was alive, basic scientific knowledge was missing. Cell theory and germ theory were a few decades from even a basic understanding.

Homeopathic potions are prepared by serially diluting the original substance (could be anything from diseased tissue to arsenic to snake venom plus mercury) with shaking by forceful striking on an elastic body, which they term succussion. Each dilution followed by succussion is assumed to increase the effectiveness. Homeopaths call this process potentization. So far, it’s just merely diluting and shaking, so nothing much there. But the level of dilution is such that there is only a tiny possibility of any molecule of the original substance showing up in solution.

The dilution is precisely described by Hahnemann. The first dilution is one part to 100 parts water. Then, one part of that is diluted in another 100 parts water. Each dilution is called 1C, so two dilutions would be called 2C, with one part of the similar diluted in 10,000 parts water. But it doesn’t stop there. Homeopathy uses >30C dilutions, which means that the dilution is simply water. At 30C, the dilution is now 1 part substance to 10^60 (or 10 followed by 60 zeroes) parts water. You would need to drink 10^34 (or 10 followed by 34 zeroes) gallons of water (which is about 10 billion times the amount of water on earth) just to get one molecule–one single molecule of the original substance. Now diluting substances to create a physiological response is a well known, evidence based method in medicine. For example, allergy hyposensitization uses extremely diluted antigens (say cat dander), while slowly increasing the concentration to build a tolerance to the immune response. But the dilution is substantially higher, maybe 1-2C at most.

So, then the homeopaths overcome this mathematical issue by stating that water has a memory. This claim is based on a long-disputed, unrepeated, and basically, disregarded experiment. Every attempt to repeat the experiment, in a double blinded manner, was a failure; so at some point, you have to say, “no it doesn’t work.” And of course, there is just no evidence that it might work. Just to be clear, there’s the clinical evidence that homeopathy absolutely doesn’t work:

The results of our meta-analysis are not compatible with the hypothesis that the clinical effects of homeopathy are completely due to placebo. However, we found insufficient evidence from these studies that homeopathy is clearly efficacious for any single clinical condition.

Then, recently, I saw this Tweet appear on my feed:

I haven’t mocked Homeopaths without Borders in a year. Homeopaths without Borders (HWB) is an American organization that claims that it provides humanitarian aid, in the form of homeopathic “medicine”, to devastated areas of the world. Of course, HWB is attempting to co-opt the name of the more famous group that does real lifesaving work across the world, Doctors without Borders, who are probably too busy, utilizing real evidence-based medicine with real medications, risking their own lives, and performing great service to humanity, to be worried that a bunch of pseudoscientific homeopaths stole their noble trademark to push quackery.

HWB has sent their water magicians to Haiti, Guatemala, Dominican Republic, Sri Lanka, and El Salvador, all countries that have suffered so much during the past few years. During their time in Haiti, “the team will be in Port-au-Prince to complete the final session of the Fundamentals Program—a foundational curriculum in homeopathic therapeutics incorporating theoretical and clinical training.” So not only are they providing nonsense, useless, unscientific healthcare to Haiti, they are training new homeopaths there. Haiti needs to train real doctors who use science based medicine, not quack medicine.

Setting aside all of my snark and all of my outrage at the homeopaths, real physicians are putting themselves at the frontline of battling this disease. A real doctor and a real nurse from the USA have contracted the disease, and they are getting the best treatment possible by the world class physicians and researchers at the CDC. (They did try an experimental method to treat the disease, but the results are unknown.) The actual Doctors without Borders (better known outside of the USA as Médecins Sans Frontières) is battling the outbreak with real medical facilities and real physicians.

MSF, the CDC and WHO have their best and brightest researchers, physicians, and other health care workers standing at the frontline of this disease. They are risking their lives through sheer bravery, no different than a soldier going into a battle. When I hear some pseudoscience-pushing lunatic (sorry, I can’t help being snarky) say that the CDC is bought off by Big Pharma or some nefarious Jewish conspiracy (no, I’m not making that up), I’d like to see them go off to West Africa and try to save lives right in the middle of an epidemic of a deadly disease.

Where are those homeopaths? Oh, they’re actually just cowards, spending their days trying to take money from saps who believe in their lies. Homeopaths aren’t going to risk their lives for free.

Actually, it’s probably good that the woo-pushers aren’t there. They’d just get in the way, end up getting sick, and a real doctor will have to try to save their lives.

 

Key citations:

Comments (35)
  • Pingback: Ebola in the News - Dr. Cheryl Kasdorf, ND

  • Pingback: Lions, tigers and ebola–oh my!

  • Kevin Worldsavior

    In any case I got the most natural weapon (just an exercise) against any viruses, known on Earth – I got the Ebola virus (any strain and mutant) devastating destroyer by which the virus is killed the moment it touches us – Its protein decoy cannot save it from being destroyed instantly – I can eliminate the Ebola crisis for just a few days – Once I am paid the corresponding funds for that.

    • http://www.skepticalraptor.com/skepticalraptorblog.php Skeptical Raptor

      Really?

  • Flemming Mathisen

    If homeopathy did not work we would not have such a discussion like the one we have here, and countless other places.
    If homeopathy does not work it would have disappeared by itself. Over time, people would have realized that this is just quack medicine.

    The reality is completely different, homeopathy is growing like never before and it’s not because people like to be fooled, but because they are actually getting help for their health problems.

    A problem that all opponents of homeopathy have is their almost religious relationship to science. Without scientific approval, in some science magazine or the like, it is impossible for these people to see the truth. It’s almost like a black curtain is pulled over their eyes.

    These people do not have an objective mind, but more similar to extremism.

    Just because science has not found if homeopathy works, or how it works, does not mean that homeopathy does not work.
    The apple fell to the ground long before Newton formulated his gravitational law.
    And there were germs and viruses etc long before science discovered them with their microscopes and experiments.

    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24685417

    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22500721

    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20043074

    • http://www.skepticalraptor.com/skepticalraptorblog.php Skeptical Raptor

      Cherry picking very bad studies? How about the hundreds of studies that show that Homeopathy is just plain water.

      And your Appeal to Popularity and Appeal to Ignorance logical fallacies are most amusing. You really have nothing.

      And your Newton strawman is laughable. Go ahead. Show us that water remembers anything but water (it can’t), you’ll have a Nobel Prize. Don’t be a coward, give us the evidence.

      We await your foolishness.

      You’re pretty lame.

  • Patriot Girl

    That’s exactly my point… you don’t know jack about homeopathy… it works on a vibrational level – you are utilizing the vibration of these elements which has an equal and opposite effect of the actual element – Nickolai Tesla said a famous scientist before him told him that all the power was in vibrational energy… You can be sure that any “clinical trials” by Big Pharma will show homeopathy doesn’t work – of course their trials show that their Big Pharma isn’t killing people either… sic – But there have been zillions of trials and research on natural remedies that show they work… but they don’t count because Big Pharma didn’t perform them… right?! It works and the big boys that charge $10 a pill for life-destroying big pharma don’t want anyone to know that…

    • http://www.skepticalraptor.com/skepticalraptorblog.php Skeptical Raptor

      I know more about homeopathy in my left pinky finger than you ever will.

      Your Big Pharma Strawman Argument was most amusing. Big Pharma’s medications save lives. Homeopathy is just expensive thirst quenching. And I thought a bottle of Evian was expensive.

      I love ignorant fools. They’re so much fun.

  • NMx

    I love how people with no knowledge or experience with homeopathy know so much about it… it would be like me giving advice on heart surgery… get a clue… homeopathy works… you just don’t know thing one about it…. I’ve seen virtual miracles with and obviously you are shills for Big Pharma…. who is killing millions annually.

    • http://www.skepticalraptor.com/skepticalraptorblog.php Skeptical Raptor

      There is simply no known way that water molecules can confer any medical benefit to anyone unless it’s dehydration. Furthermore, the implausibility of such a “belief” is such that if we assumed that water had such power, we would have to suspend all of our knowledge of physics, quantum mechanics, and chemistry. It would be Nobel Prize worthy knowledge.

      More than that, short of poorly designed studies published in low ranked journals, every stitch of evidence in high quality systematic reviews has shown that the scientific evidence simply refutes the possibility that homeopathy has any clinically significant effect.

      Thus, homeopathy fails because it is utterly implausible, if not impossible. And second it fails because clinical trials have shown it doesn’t work.

      So, yes, I have knowledge with homeopathy. It is garbage. And your anecdotes have all the validity of cat feces. Meaning, it stinks, and it needs to be thrown in the trash.

  • bernadette Sullivan
    • http://www.skepticalraptor.com/skepticalraptorblog.php Skeptical Raptor

      Non-peer-reviewed garbage. Homeopathy is implausible. And it has no clinical effect.

      We’re done.

  • Bertrande

    Water magicians! Love it.

  • Vickie Zisman

    Just shared on my Twitter. A must read. This whole New Age fluff is plain dangerous. They have flipped the common sense from the legs to the head and turned the conventional medicine and doctors into the Forces of Dark, conspiring to ruin humanity through dangerous practices and “greedy” alliances with the Pharma companies. How easy to do that, living in a 21st century with the unprecedented longevity, achieved precisely thanks to those trashed forces of dark and their greedy allies.

  • lilady R.N.

    More information from CNN, about the experimental treatment, which was used to treat the two American patients in Liberia:

    http://www.cnn.com/2014/08/04/health/experimental-ebola-serum/index.html

  • Pingback: » Twitter makes my Ebola tweet go ironically viral

  • Pingback: Your Ebola reading list: Should you worry? « Red Wine & Apple Sauce

  • Pingback: Homeopathy and Ebola - Plague of Mice

  • Martha

    Know more about homeopathy on a deeper level before dissing it. It cured 80% in the 1919 flu epidemic, whereas regular medicine lost 80%.

    • http://www.skepticalraptor.com/skepticalraptorblog.php Skeptical Raptor

      Evidence please. And it better be in the form of peer reviewed historical or medical analyses of the 1918 (get the date right) epidemic.

      Here’s thing. I know more about homeopathy in my left testicle than you know in your uneducated bunch of neural matter that you claim is a brain. There is NO plausible chemical or physical mechanics that could make homeopathy work. There are no clinical trials that show it works.

      So you are sadly misinformed, a problem with people like you.

      • Anon

        Not saying Homeopathy works. But this current Ebola outbreak has a mortality rate of 60%. Yes, Ebola can have a mortality rate of 90% but could be confused that this was referring to the current situation. So perhaps someone incorrectly dating flu epidemic as 1919 can be forgiven too.

        • http://www.skepticalraptor.com/skepticalraptorblog.php Skeptical Raptor

          90% is based on evidence published in journals. Your comments have the value of homeopathy.

          • Ben Fairbanks

            Oooo! A bit touchy? The 60% isn’t wrong, even if it is a gross simplification of complex and heterogeneous data.
            http://scienceblogs.com/gregladen/2014/07/27/ebola-outbreak-in-west-africa-some-basic-information/
            Regardless, as you say, any reasonable person cannot but conclude that mortality is remarkably high and homeopathy won’t do diddly. Or perhaps, inasmuch as it is pure water, it could help to keep Ebola sufferers hydrated, if taken intravenously with a little salt and in sufficient quantities.

          • http://www.skepticalraptor.com/skepticalraptorblog.php Skeptical Raptor

            An “Anon” commenter shows up and says something dumbass. I get to call him that. I’m mean to everyone I don’t like. It’s just me.

            You should see what I say about Mr. Andy Wakefield, the fraud and criminal.

            Not touchy at all. You should know better.

          • notation

            I knew there was a reason I liked you.

  • http://www.rosner.net.nz Adam Rosner

    How to test homeopathic dilutions for efficacy: Find a person with a lethal nut allergy. The type of person who will die if they walk past a shop that in 1975 once sold a jar of peanut butter… make a 30C homeopathic dilution of peanut oil. Administer to test subject. Watch them not die. Increase to 20C and then 10C etc – Continue until symptoms appear. This is the minimum effective dilution for homeopathy.

    • http://www.skepticalraptor.com/skepticalraptorblog.php Skeptical Raptor

      But that’s science, something beyond the skill set of your typical homeopath.

  • http://beginingsinwriting.wordpress.com/ R.w. Foster

    Awww. The Raptor is tired today. I saw the title of your post and I was thinking I’d get a ton of snark. (pouts)

    • http://www.skepticalraptor.com/skepticalraptorblog.php Skeptical Raptor

      I’m so sorry. Maybe next time!

      • http://beginingsinwriting.wordpress.com/ R.w. Foster

        There we go! :D

  • Rayne

    Fun fact: When I tweeted the tweet I didn’t actually know Homeopaths without Borders was an actual organisation.

    • http://www.skepticalraptor.com/skepticalraptorblog.php Skeptical Raptor

      No kidding. That is a hysterically Fun Fact.

    • turtlegirl784

      Fun fact: I had no idea it existed until I read this post. Ugh.

      • http://www.skepticalraptor.com/skepticalraptorblog.php Skeptical Raptor

        So are you implying I’m giving them too much advertising space? LOL

  • http://www.handmadedresshaven.blogspot.com Kathy

    oh good grief, homeopathy for ebola. That is pathetic.

Powered by WordPress 4.0
Don't forget to subscribe to this blog through any the services in the right sidebar.