Skip to content
Home » Debunking popular cancer myths found on the internet

Debunking popular cancer myths found on the internet


I keep responding to these cancer myths all across the internet, so I thought that it might be useful to list out my favorite ones. Unfortunately, it would take 100,000 words to debunk all of these cancer myths, and I’m pretty sure none of you would want to read all of that.

For example, the Burzynski Clinic quackery is best handled by a real cancer specialist, David Gorski, MD, who has written well over 100 articles critiquing the Burzynski pseudoscience. So I’m sticking with my personal favorites.

Unfortunately, people search the internet for information that confirms their bias about cancer. They just want to believe that Big Pharma is hiding the one cure for cancer. Or physicians just want to “treat” cancer and not cure it. Or that drinking the infamous blueberry kale smoothie will somehow make you immune to cancer. Or there’s a secret cure in some secret facility in Mexico that will quickly “cure” cancer while sipping margaritas.

This article will examine some of these cancer myths, and I’ll do my best to debunk them.

modern hospital chemotherapy room setup
Photo by Andre on Pexels.com

What is cancer?

Simply, cancer is a group of diseases characterized by abnormal cell growth that can invade or metastasize to other tissues and organs. Although people use tumor and cancer interchangeably, not all tumors are cancers. Benign tumors do not metastasize and are not cancers.

Cancer usually requires numerous, possibly up to 10, independent genetic mutations in a population of cells before it can become a growing, metastatic cancer. Each mutation is selected, as in natural selection, because it provides some benefit to the cancer cell, such as causing blood vessels to supply the cells with nutrition and oxygen, or the ability to divide rapidly, whatever the feature is.

These mutations can have many different causes. The environment (like smoking or UV radiation), viruses (hepatitis B and human papillomavirus are the most common), genes, and just random chance (we’ll discuss this cause in detail below) can contribute to an increased risk of cancer.

You can do a few things to prevent cancer, such as quitting smoking, staying out of the sun, getting your hepatitis B and HPV vaccinations, not drinking alcohol, keeping a low body weight, and eating a balanced diet. But even if you are a paragon of healthy living, a random mutation in some cell in your body can lead to cancer.

Four paragraphs can hardly do justice to the mountains of published scientific research on cancer. PubMed lists nearly 4 million (yes, million) articles on cancer. I admit I haven’t read all 4 million, though I have read a few hundred, especially on HPV and current cancer treatments.

I am a cancer survivor. I utilized science-based medicine to treat and ultimately conquer that cancer. Lucky me, there’s been no recurrence after nearly 40 years. I did not turn to fake science like vitamin C or a colon detox – I relied upon the best practices of my oncologist, surgeon, and primary care physician (along with the battalion of nurses, techs, friends, and family).

a woman wearing headscarf having a treatment while lying on hospital bed
Photo by Ivan S on Pexels.com

Cancer myths – all cancers are the same

Cancer is a generic word that covers what I stated above – it’s a cell or group of cells that undergo uncontrolled cellular growth and metastasize into other cells and organs. However, cancer is not one disease.

The National Cancer Institute states that there are over 100 types of cancer.  Cancer Research UK states that there are over 200 types of cancer. The American Cancer Society lists over 70 types of cancer (although some are more classes of cancer rather than a single type). Wikipedia lists over 180 different cancers.

Because different cancers aren’t precisely defined, the actual number varies. It’s possible to argue that there are orders of magnitude more cancers because cancer in one person may have different characteristics and cellular mutations than cancer in another.

Nevertheless, each of these cancers has different etiologies (causes), pathophysiologies (development), prognosis, and treatment.

Whenever I read some internet quack claim that there is a cure for cancer, I laugh because I know that they don’t understand the nature of cancer. Maybe someday, well into the future, we might have a scientific “aha” moment and find a common link between all cancers, but that seems implausible. It is not one disease.

Also, if I see some internet quack proclaim that they have the sure-thing cure for cancer, I laugh until I remember that they’re selling that junk to innocent people who think it might help.

bacteria on white background
Photo by Marek Piwnicki on Pexels.com

Cancer myths – one cure to cure them all

Because there are hundreds of different cancers, it will take hundreds of different treatments to treat them all. Cancer treatment isn’t based on wild claims on the internet; it’s based on scientific and clinical evidence, not anecdotes and pseudoscientific claims.

Again, maybe one day we’ll find a common biological trait across cancers that we can attack to stop them. I’m skeptical of ever finding that, but there might be some common attribute between a handful of cancers that might be a target of cancer therapy. Cancer vaccines and immunotherapy depend on commonalities among cancers.

Right now, we rely upon a strategy of surgery (for most cancers) and adjuvant therapies like chemo- and radiotherapy. The success of these therapeutic strategies depends on the evidence published in those 4 million articles on cancer.

Although a few drugs can be used across different cancers, each cancer usually requires a different treatment strategy. In today’s world of cancer treatment, there is no one drug to treat them all.

Of course, many cancer experts are reluctant to use the word “cure.” They prefer words like “remission” or “five-year survival,” which may sound like euphemisms but are more accurate. It is almost impossible to determine if every single cancer cell has been eliminated, so cancer recurrence can arise from just a few cells that survived.

Nevertheless, the one cancer cure to cure them all is probably a mirage that people want to believe exists, but from a biological standpoint, it probably doesn’t exist.

photo of woman resting on the couch
Photo by Cedric Fauntleroy on Pexels.com

Cancer myths – we’re losing the war on cancer

Even though there will probably never be one cure to cure them all, it doesn’t mean that we have been unsuccessful against cancer. Recent research has shown that cancer mortality rates have dropped in men, women, children, and most (but not all) racial and ethnic groups in the USA.

From 1991 through 2024, the last year included in the study, the mortality rate from cancer in the USA has declined by over 35%, averting over five million cancer deaths. That decline was largely driven by decreased smoking rates and an ensuing decline in lung cancer deaths, a trend that accelerated due to advances in early detection and treatment.

Declines in death rates for colorectal cancer and breast cancer over the past three decades have also been key in reducing the overall U.S. cancer mortality rate

Despite the wild cancer myths, medicine is doing an excellent job of defeating cancer. Better and earlier detection of cancer (thanks to science), more effective treatments (thanks to science), and better long-term care (thanks to science) have led to this remarkable reduction in cancer mortality.

Many of the 200 or more cancers have been effectively defeated by modern science-based medicine. Acute lymphoblastic leukemia, the most common form of leukemia in children, used to be a death sentence for children. However, powerful new therapies increased five-year survival for children from under 10% in the 1960s to 90% in 2015.

Many other cancers that used to be hopeless have also seen remarkable survival improvements.

faceless doctor with pills in hands
Photo by https://kaboompics.com/ on Pexels.com

Cancer myths – Big Pharma is hiding THE cure

Of course, as we pointed out above, it is ridiculous to believe that there is one cure for all 200 or more different cancers. It’s unscientific and stretches the bounds of biological plausibility. And, as we saw above, many cancers have been attacked successfully by treatments marketed by Big Pharma. Sure, they make a boatload of money from these treatments (and that becomes another argument for another day), but they also work (which refutes another one of those silly cancer myths pushed by the ignorant).

But let’s pretend this imaginary one cure-to-cure-them-all, purified from the rainbow farts of unicorns, actually exists. How would Big Pharma deal with this mythical cure?

  1. Despite the conspiracy theories, Big Pharma is hardly one monolithic monopoly. Nearly 20,000 biopharmaceutical companies operate across the developed world. And many of them loathe each other – they couldn’t give a Rattus norvegicus‘ gluteus maximus about one another. If one prospered and one disappeared, there would be cheers for the successful one. If one company invented this cure, they wouldn’t think for one nanosecond of any other company or its bottom line.
  2. Big Pharma does not engage in groupthink about cancer treatment – many of these companies can only focus on a handful of treatments, not treatments for all 200 or more cancers. Considering the cost of developing a single drug, which can exceed US$1 billion, along with the high rate of failure, where 90% of new cancer drugs never get approved by the FDA and other regulatory bodies across the world, most companies only focus on a handful of cancers and drugs.
  3. There is literally no way to keep this imaginary cure secret. Big Pharma rarely does cancer research by itself in a secret underground laboratory under the Antarctic Ice Sheet managed by the Reptilian Overlords. Usually, cancer research is a collaboration between research universities and hospitals, the government (like the National Cancer Institute), and pharmaceutical companies. Preliminary research would be published in peer-reviewed journals and discussed in large scientific meetings. Everyone would know about it. Of course, the most important research would have to be done in large clinical trials, all of which require Institutional Review Board approval for ethics, FDA approval to start clinical trials, and listing in the clinical trials database.
  4. And let’s not forget about social media – how many participants in a clinical trial will post it on Facebook? How many would hear about it and demand the drug for themselves, their mothers, their children, and their friends? Furthermore, since this research isn’t done by 10 people in a secret underground bunker, there will be dozens, maybe hundreds, of employees of this Big Pharma corporation who would know about the drug. They’d demand it too.
  5. Finally, if we’re going to subscribe to some lame conspiracy theory, let’s be logically consistent. If you want to believe that Big Pharma will hide a cure because they’re making a few billion off a handful of cancer treatments, then we need to accept that they would want to make hundreds of billions of dollars from this magical cure. If they owned this cure, they could charge almost any price, and millions of people would pay. They would tell countries that try to regulate their prices to go jump in a lake. Pay $1 million per dose, or your citizens won’t get it (they wouldn’t do this, but I’m just trying to be consistent with the conspiracy). Of course, if they did this to Germany, all the wealthy Germans would fly to the USA for treatment. Big Pharma execs would line the boardroom with bars of gold if they were the ones to discover the magical, mythical cancer cure.
  6. Wait, there’s one more, finally. This ridiculous cancer myth depends on an inane belief that every employee of Big Pharma lacks morals or ethics. Someone would blow the whistle. Maybe because she wants to make sure her dad gets the treatment.

Cancer myths – something causes cancer

People think that cancer is caused by some on/off switch. That’s not quite accurate. There are some smokers who don’t get lung cancer. And there are some individuals who never smoke who do get lung cancer. Now, let me be perfectly clear – I am not saying that smoking is fine. In fact, smokers are 15-30 times more likely to contract lung cancer than non-smokers.

Many researchers accept that most genetic mutations which lead to cancer are more or less random, just bad luck. In this 2017 study, the authors analyzed data for 32 cancer types and found that about two-thirds of the mutations in these cancers resulted from random or spontaneous errors in DNA. The data came from 69 countries across six continents, where researchers found a statistically significant correlation between cancer incidence and the total number of stem cell divisions. Moreover, this correlation held globally, regardless of the environment.

The original 2015 study, authored by Cristian Tomasetti, a biostatistician interested in cancer evolution, genomics, and stem cell dynamics, and Bert Vogelstein, who is one of the preeminent leaders in cancer research, first proposed the hypothesis that cancer was mostly “bad luck.” That article generated dozens of published comments (no, not like what you find on Facebook, but published in subsequent issues of Science).

David Gorski, a surgical oncologist, wrote about this study in 2015 in Science-Based Medicine. Although Dr. Gorski does criticize some parts of the paper by Tomasetti and Vogelstein, overall he does indicate that random mutations are responsible for a large majority of cancers:

Given the level of uncertainty inherent in such estimates, even if you interpret Vogelstein and Tomasetti’s conclusion that two thirds of cancers are due to “bad luck,” their estimate of the percentage of cancers that are probably not preventable is definitely in the ballpark of commonly-accepted estimates, albeit at the lower end. Does that mean they’re on to something in concluding that stem cell replication over one’s lifetime primarily determines the “stochastic” component of cancer risk for each organ? That remains to be seen, but their preliminary finding makes sense, both from the perspective of producing a result that’s in the ballpark of what we already know based on epidemiology and being biologically plausible based on basic cancer biology.

Let’s look at it another way. The average body has around 50 trillion cells, each containing over 3 billion DNA base pairs. That’s 150,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 DNA base pairs in each person. Even though people believe that their cells are “perfect” in replicating themselves, that’s not true. Errors may occur in human cells anywhere from 0.0001% to as high as 1% of base pairs. That could mean billions of mutations, and although most are corrected by cellular machinery, many could still lead to cancer.

No, there’s nothing you can do about this. You cannot down a bunch of vitamin C, become vegan, or drink some special concoction pushed by your local naturopathic quack to reduce the number of mutations. These base-pair errors are just very rare events that result from chemical interactions of nucleotides in the cell.

cancer myths

Cancer myths – yeah, but XYZ causes cancer

Despite the fact that 2/3 of cancers have no cause except random mutations, 1/3 of cancers do have some link to an environmental issue. But let’s look at what those are:

  1. Smoking.
  2. Second-hand smoke.
  3. UV radiation from the sun or tanning beds.
  4. Vaccine-preventable viruses like HPV and hepatitis B.
  5. Obesity.
  6. Radiation (which includes the ubiquitous radon gas found in many homes).
  7. Alcohol.
  8. Poor diet.
  9. Sedentary lifestyle.
  10. Airborne pollutants.

Most of these are preventable, or at least you can significantly influence them.

The average American, Canadian, or European has around a 50% chance of contracting cancer over a lifetime. That means out of 100,000 people, 50,000 will have to deal with cancer at least once. Almost all of those 50,000 cases result from random mutations or one of the 10 issues listed above.

Let’s say that someone says drinking coffee is linked to cancer. Instead of 50,000 cases, we might see 50,001 cases. It’s not going to mean that we’d see 100,000 cases. Remember, it’s not an on/off switch; it’s a tiny increase in risk.

Moreover, do you know how difficult it is to distinguish 50,000 from 50,001 cases of cancer? It’s next to impossible. We’d need a powerful epidemiological or clinical study with over 50 billion participants (about 7X the number of people on the planet) to detect such a small change in cancer risk. In other words, we wouldn’t be able to tell you that the cancer was linked to coffee or just one additional random mutation.  Or some particle of smoke from the cigar smoker in the car next to you while you’re jogging along the street.

Summary

There are a lot of cancer myths out there. Most of them are based on a lack of understanding of cancer science, embracing ridiculous conspiracy theories, and internal logical errors.

These myths would be amusing except for people who might decide to refuse science-based medicine and rely upon quacks and charlatans who push these myths for their own profits.

Cancer is a scary disease. I remember getting diagnosed with cancer, and I couldn’t sleep well for a few weeks. But I asked my oncologist a lot of questions (lucky for me, I have a substantial science and medical background, so I knew what to ask), so I felt better. And this was in the ancient world of cancer treatment.

Hopefully, this list will help some of you reject the crackpot cancer myths.

Citations

Help the Skeptical Raptor keep writing internet medical myths

There are four ways you can help contribute to keeping this website running at full speed:

  1. GoFundMe.
  2. Subscribing via Patreon.
  3. Buying your favorite stuff on Amazon.
  4. Sharing this article on Social Media.

Don’t miss each new article!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Liked it? Take a second to support Michael Simpson on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!


Discover more from Skeptical Raptor

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Discover more from Skeptical Raptor

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading