Skip to content
Home » Why we immunize against the flu–save healthy children’s lives

Why we immunize against the flu–save healthy children’s lives

flu 20shotIf you break your arm, go to an emergency department, you see that medicine has an effect. Your fracture is set (very painful), and then you have a cast (very itchy). You can observe, without much bias, that a physician and his medical knowledge has fixed you. And you can show everyone else your cast, get it signed, and tell everyone how brave you were!

On the other hand, vaccinations can seem like they really don’t do anything. We get vaccinated, and it keeps us healthy–but it’s really hard to see that it does anything. Basically, vaccines maintain your default standard of health (at least what you think is the standard), so showing off your post-vaccination bandage doesn’t have the same effect. The cause and effect is just not there.

But there are real stories of tragedies for adults and children who aren’t vaccinated.

For example, there is one vaccine that seems to be ignored or outright avoided, even by seemingly rational people who get vaccines for everything else–the flu vaccine. Many people seem to invent myths about this vaccine, or accept those myths more readily than they do for other vaccines, all of which are easily dismissed and debunked.

I don’t know what causes this one vaccine to be so easily rejected by so many people, but it could be that the central myth of the flu itself is that it isn’t dangerous. People really believe that no one gets hurt from the flu. Especially themselves. 

We know that polio can paralyze. Or that measles might kill. Or that whooping cough is dangerous. So vaccines for those diseases seem to be mostly acceptable to 95% of Americans, and quite frankly, to most of the world (pdf). But the flu vaccine just gets relegated to same healthcare category as when your physician tells you to get more exercise. Or eat less red meat. Or get more sleep.

In the USA, people recently overdramatized the risk of Ebola, but completely ignore the fact that the flu actually is substantially more dangerous than Ebola. In 2012-13, over 140,000 Americans were hospitalized because of the flu (pdf). But worse yet, 169 children died from the flu, most were not vaccinated.  As of today, not a single child has died in the US from Ebola, yet hundreds of children die from the flu, which is prevented by vaccines, every year.

But these aren’t just numbers. There are real parents having real funerals because of the flu.

Ten years ago, a healthy four year old girl, Amanda Kanowitz of Scarsdale, NY, died from complications of the flu, two days after catching it. Amanda was one of 153 children who died of the flu that season (ironically, the first that the CDC began to track pediatric mortality), most of whom were healthy, like Amanda.

Her parents didn’t have her vaccinated against the seasonal flu because, in 2003-04, the flu vaccine wasn’t indicated for children older than 2 years. Precisely because their family pediatrician, following CDC and FDA recommendations, didn’t vaccinate Amanda (a medically appropriate choice at the time), she caught the flu. According to Amanda’s father, Richard Kanowitz, “her body couldn’t fight the virus and didn’t know how to regulate itself. It was her body’s immune system and the reaction to the virus that killed it.” In fact, in 2006, after impassioned pleas from Amanda’s parents, the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) recommended that the pediatric flu vaccine include children up to 8 years old.

The flu can overwhelm an immature immune system, but even with a four year old child, the effects of the flu can kill. Excess mucus can cause labored breathing, for example, leading to secondary pneumonia. It can cause organs to shut down, as the immune system battles the flu virus. One moment, your child is healthy and playing tag with her siblings, and in just a few hours, she’s fighting for her life. And it can be prevented with a simple shot, and it’s horrifying to me that parents lost a child because they didn’t refuse a vaccine for Amanda, but because of timing of safety data accumulation from the manufacturer meant it wasn’t approved.

(As a side note, and certainly not to make this story worse, I ignore all age recommendations on vaccines for myself and children. Age cut-offs on package inserts are arbitrary. And my radical behavior only applies to vaccines.)

And remember, the flu virus doesn’t just appear out of thin air and dropped onto children. They must catch it from someone who is infected with the virus, who probably didn’t get the flu vaccine because they think that the flu isn’t all that dangerous. Or something ridiculous.

Setting aside all the lies, myths, misinformation, and outright delusion, flu is dangerous to everyone. I wrote about a healthy teenage girl who has chronic health issues from a severe bout of flu. These aren’t just random stories, they are real parents and real children who are attacked by the virus. Yes, the flu is more dangerous to those who are older, who have chronic health issues, who are immune-suppressed, and to young children.

Maybe you, the reader, think you’re a healthy 25 year old who really doesn’t need the flu shot. Maybe you think you’ve never had the flu, or it’s just not going to do anything to you. But what if you were the one person that passes the flu to a young child who then dies of it. Yes, you can help stop the spread of the flu. Of course, over 50,000 Americans died of the flu (or complications) in the 2011-12 (pdf), many of them healthy young people, just like you.

The flu vaccine is safe, as safe as any vaccine out there. It’s safe for pregnant women. It doesn’t cause neurological disorders. There is overwhelming evidence that debunks every common myth about the safety of the flu vaccine.

Amanda’s parents have become well-known advocates of the flu vaccine for children. No they’re not being paid by Big Pharma to do it. They do it because they have 2 other children, both of whom get their annual flu vaccine, and because they know what it feels like (something I could not begin to imagine) to lose a child to a “not-very-dangerous disease.”

For those readers who want the quick version:

  • Vaccinate your children against the flu
  • Vaccinate yourself against the flu to protect others and yourself
  • Think of Amanda Kanowitz. Today, she would have gotten the vaccine, and she would probably be a happy, giggling four year old with an infectious smile.

Save your life. Save the lives of children. Get the flu vaccine.


Try the Science-based Vaccine Search Engine.


Michael Simpson
Liked it? Take a second to support Michael Simpson on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!

Discover more from Skeptical Raptor

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Discover more from Skeptical Raptor

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading