Last updated on December 22nd, 2025 at 12:31 pm
This article, regarding several health organizations suing RFK Jr over his recent COVID vaccines decision, was written by Dorit Rubinstein Reiss, Professor of Law at the University of California Law San Francisco, who is a frequent contributor to this and many other websites, providing in-depth and intellectually stimulating articles about vaccines, medical issues, social policy, and the law.
Professor Reiss writes extensively about the social and legal aspects of vaccination in law journals. Reiss is also a member of the Parent Advisory Board of Voices for Vaccines. This parent-led organization supports and advocates for on-time vaccination and the reduction of vaccine-preventable diseases. She is also a member of the Vaccines Working Group on Ethics and Policy.
On 7 June 2025, a lawsuit was filed in a district court in Massachusetts challenging HHS Secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr’s (RFK Jr) decision to overturn the recommendation that pregnant women and healthy children receive COVID-19 vaccines. This post examines the lawsuit and puts it in a legal context. For full disclosure, I stated my position that the Secretary’s actions cannot legally stand in multiple forums before this, and I discussed this lawsuit before its start multiple times with people involved (though I am not part of the litigation team, nor working for them, nor financially benefitting from the litigation in any way).

Background on RFK Jr’s decision about COVID vaccines
As readers are likely aware, on 27 May 2025, Secretary Kennedy rescinded the recommendation for COVID-19 vaccines for pregnant women and healthy children. The Secretary did not follow the usual process of convening the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), having it examine large amounts of data, and voting after careful deliberation.
Instead, he announced the decision in a video of less than one minute on a private platform – X – a video in which he appears with the new Commissioner of FDA, Dr. Martin Makary, and the Director of NIH, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, neither of which have a legal role in vaccine recommendations – and nobody from CDC, which does have a role in it.
In addition, in the lead-up to the decision, the Secretary sent an internal memo to HHS ordering the removal of the recommendation. Both the video and the memo were very short on substantive explanation, and neither was published in any way that would count in the administrative state, nor was it subject to any serious deliberation. The decisions were also in tension with the scientific data. My co-authors and I have discussed these points before, so there is no need to repeat them.
On Monday, 7 July 2025, several organizations – the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), The American College of Physicians (ACP), The American Public Health Association (APHA), The Infectious Disease Society of America (IDSA), the Massachusetts Public Health Alliance, and the Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine – and one individual plaintiff, at this point kept anonymous and referred to as “Jane Doe” (legalese for a female plaintiff whose name, for now, is kept hidden), was filed in the federal district court in Massachusetts. The lawsuit was assigned to Judge William G. Young, initially nominated by President Ronald Reagan, who had already ruled against HHS on a previous case, related to its rescinding of NIH grants.
The lawsuit goes into much more detail than I did into Kennedy’s actions, and provides a good overview of vaccine decision infrastructure, but I will focus on the legal arguments, and recommend reading the lawsuit for the rest.
The lawsuit’s greatest challenge was finding someone who had standing to sue, and the lawsuit spends quite some time making a strong case for that. If there is a plaintiff with standing – and I think the lawsuit did a good job finding such people, so this is something readers may be able to help with, too – the arguments against Secretary Kennedy’s actions are very, very strong.
Let’s go over this.

Standing on lawsuit against RFK Jr over COVID vaccines decision
In the United States federal courts, you cannot bring abstract cases (note: there are systems where you can ask courts abstract legal questions; even some states have looser requirements than the federal government). The Constitution, as interpreted by our judges, requires that to bring a case in federal court, the plaintiff must show that:
(1) he/she has suffered a distinct and palpable injury as a result of the putatively illegal conduct of the defendant;
(2) the injury is fairly traceable to the challenged conduct; and
(3) it is likely to be redressed if the requested relief is granted.
See Valley Forge Christian College v. Americans United for Separation of Church and State, Inc.
It’s not enough to show that the administration ignored norms of good government and violated rules; you need to establish direct harm from it. This was the first hurdle the lawsuit needed to overcome.
It is enough if one plaintiff has standing, so I will start from the end. One of the plaintiffs in the lawsuit is Jane Doe, a pregnant woman who was already vaccinated against COVID-19, but who testified that her doctors recommended another vaccine, and she is running into obstacles getting it because of Secretary Kennedy’s decision to remove the vaccine from the recommended list. Since she is having trouble getting access to the vaccine because of Kennedy’s actions, she has a fairly direct injury.
In addition, the lawsuit suggests standing for the organizations in the lawsuit. An organization can have standing in one of two ways: for injuries to its members, when:
“(a) its members would otherwise have standing to sue in their own right;
(b) the interests it seeks to protect are germane to the organization’s purpose; and
(c) neither the claim asserted nor the relief requested requires the participation of individual members in the lawsuit.”
Or directly, if it can itself meet the requirements of standing.
The lawsuit is mostly focused on injury to members of the different organizations, and raises many ways they were, allegedly, harmed. Without covering all the arguments, here is one example:
Shannon E. Scott-Vernaglia, MD, is a board-certified pediatrician practicing in Boston, Massachusetts. She is a member of the American Academy of Pediatrics. She treats patients in a pediatric clinic that distributes vaccines, including the COVID-19 vaccine, through the Vaccines for Children Program.
The Secretary’s Directive has limited her clinic’s ability to consistently stock COVID-19 vaccinations for healthy children. She attests that there is clear scientific evidence that missed opportunities for vaccination during regular office visits lead to a greater risk of future immunization status for children, and having irregular or uncertain vaccine availability due to the Secretary’s Directive puts her patients at risk of remaining unvaccinated in the future.
Additional claims include doctors testifying that they had to turn patients away for lack of COVID-19 vaccines or face financial harm because “some insurers do not cover vaccines that are not on the CDC immunization schedules.” Or, a clinic testifies it can no longer purchase COVID-19 vaccines for pregnant women at a “super low price” since that price only applies to vaccines recommended by the CDC, putting them at financial risk. Another association reported on patients denied vaccines at multiple pharmacies.
Less direct, and hence, in my view, less strong, several of the association members testified to confusion and hesitancy among their patients from the change of recommendations, which requires more advising and time with patients, and undermining the doctor/patient relationship.
Standing, again, is likely to be the most challenging hurdle to the lawsuit; the litigators clearly put substantial efforts into finding concrete and direct harms to members.
If readers know of other cases of people directly harmed by Secretary Kennedy’s actions, sending them the lawyers’ way would not hurt, though.

Arbitrary and capricious actions
Our administrative law jurisprudence requires agencies to explain their actions, and actions that are arbitrary and capricious can and will be struck down by the courts. This is, in a sense, a dual requirement. The agency has to explain the decision in real time (not for litigation.
The record supporting the decision should accompany it, it should address the relevant points, and the explanation should be good and valid. A new administration’s different view of an issue is not, itself, enough to change the agency’s opinion; the agency still needs to explain its new decision well.
The complaint points out that Secretary Kennedy’s actions would have real trouble meeting this standard.
- First, seven days before the decision, Drs. Makary and Prasad published an article in which they said that it is: “the policy position of the Food and Drug Administration” that “[p]regnancy and recent pregnancy were underlying medical conditions that increased a person’s risk of severe COVID-19.” The secretary never explained why he is ignoring this position as a part of HHS and deciding that pregnant people do not need protection from COVID-19 anymore. In fact, in the short video, he and his collaborators gave no explanation – none – for removing the pregnancy recommendations. In the internal memo, there was a short paragraph on it.
- As the lawsuit pointed out, the Secretary never explained what changed that made him make this decision when he did. Why do it?
- The lawsuit said, “the Directive states that the Secretary based his decision with regard to children ages six months to 17 years on review of the recommendation of the FDA and National Institutes of Health,” but he did not identify the recommendation or recommendations to which he was referring that prompted him to issue the Directive when he did;” – in other words, Secretary Kennedy, show us your data. Explain yourself. You did not even try. Referring to a recommendation without showing it is not enough. What was the data that the recommendation relied on? Does it make sense? The heart of the arbitrary and capricious standard is that agencies need to show their work, and the Secretary did not. As a sidebar, Secretary Kennedy – in this decision (and others) – is badly failing his commitment, repeated many times, to “radical transparency.” He did not make his reasoning transparent.
- Why did the secretary ignore the long-standing process of going through ACIP and deliberation? The Secretary does not tell us this, either. And it makes his decision look even more capricious, with an ACIP meeting scheduled not a month after the decision.
- Where is the consultation or deliberation here? This decision does not look like it was thought through or deliberated with anyone.
- In the April 15-16 meeting, CDC staff presented evidence that the COVID vaccines were important in pregnancy, and safe and effective in protecting pregnant people, newborns, and children. This was the last information publicly presented before the Secretary’s video. The Secretary did not explain why he is ignoring that information.
I just do not see how RFK Jr will be able to argue that a one-minute video and a short, cursory internal memo on COVID vaccines provide enough explanation for the decision, let alone enough information for deviating from previous agency data, decisions, and publications.

RFK Jr’s statutory violations in COVID vaccines recommendations
In addition to being arbitrary and capricious, the lawsuit alleges – persuasively – that the decision violates laws, drawing on 5 U.S.C. § 706(2)(A), (D), which say that a court must “hold unlawful and set aside agency action, findings, and conclusions found to be … not in accordance with law; … [or] without observance of procedure required by law; …”
The lawsuit reminds us that ACIP’s authority has been codified in multiple statutes, including §2713 of the Affordable Care Act, which encodes coverage for preventive services, and gives the power to enact it to ACIP (after recommendations are approved by CDC director) and also codified in the 21st Century Cures Act, §3901-3903.
Without a director, the Secretary has the authority to overturn ACIP, but simply ignoring the process is ignoring what Congress put in place – and the executive’s job is to “take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed” (weird capitalization in the original text of the Constitution), not to ignore Congressional laws. Kennedy simply ignored and sidestepped ACIP’s and CDC’s role, and did not even try to justify it. There, again, it’s unclear what he can say to defend it.
Based on the lack of explanation and ignoring the statutes, the lawsuit asks the court to overturn Kennedy’s decision to remove the recommendations for COVID-19 vaccines for children and pregnant women. I will update you as the lawsuit proceeds.

MAHA Institute response
On 8 July 2025, the MAHA Institute sent to its subscribers a message with the heading “MAHA Institute Condemns Lawsuit Against Secretary Kennedy as Judicial Overreach and Attempted Regulatory Capture.”
It’s not public, as far as I can see, but I was asked to address it, so I will say a few things. First, the title itself is telling. There is no judicial action yet, so how would it be “judicial overreach” unless the MAHA institute assumes Secretary Kennedy is going to lose?
Second, how can a lawsuit – win or lose – be regulatory capture? Regulatory capture is when industry is so involved with the agency that the agency does what it wants. Suing an agency for a bad decision isn’t it.
Third, the letter did not actually – in any way – address the lawsuit’s arguments. The letter does not address the lack of explanation and how the decision can withstand the arbitrary and capricious standard. It argues that Senator Kennedy’s directive “was grounded in substantial review of post-marketing data, clinical literature, and risk-benefit reassessment…” – but the Secretary’s materials did not include any such review (and the post-decision justification the Secretary sent – non-publicly – to some stakeholders had its issues, and this kind of post-hoc questions and answers is not a basis for the decision, even if it did not have scientific studies that “are unpublished or under dispute” and even if it did not mischaracterize other studies).
The MAHA institute cannot actually explain Secretary Kennedy’s decision for him. The letter argues that “[t]he evidentiary record was entered into the Federal Register, reviewed by departmental counsel, and communicated in public briefings.”
Where, exactly? The Secretary did not publish the decision in the register, and the short Twitter/X video did not communicate a record; it did not mention any study, did not explain the decision about pregnancy at all, and did not provide more than general statements about children. That is not an evidentiary record.
Oh, and the case the letter cited? Collins v. Yellen? I happen to know that case. It’s about the President’s removal power – when can Congress limit the ability of the President to remove an official? It’s not actually focused on use of discretion, and the statement by the MAHA Institute that it says that “executive decisions by statutorily authorized agency heads are presumptively lawful if made within the scope of their authority and in procedural compliance” is not a focus in the case – in fact, I could not find anything resembling that in the case in searches. If there is a statement along these lines, it’s not the basis of the decision. This is a misuse of a case.
The MAHA Institute claims that the Secretary can, essentially, reassign agency functions at will. Its letter refers to 42 U.S.C. § 202. This section reads:
“The Public Health Service in the Department of Health and Human Services shall be administered by the Assistant Secretary for Health under the supervision and direction of the Secretary.”
It does not say anywhere that the Secretary can ignore established procedures with a statutory basis (it does not even say the Secretary can reassign functions at will). The letter references the Reorganization plan of 1953.
They did not bother to link or cite it, so here it is. This plan is about creating the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare. It’s not about allowing the Secretary to ignore ACIP at all (ACIP was created later, anyway). It does not give the Secretary the authority to waive legal provisions. In fact, at the end of ¶§7 of the reorganization plan, which allows the Secretary to create some services to help the agency function (administrative services), the section concluded that “no professional or substantive function vested by law in any officer shall be removed from the jurisdiction of such officer under this section.” It’s unclear how this short law gives, in the MAHA institute’s opinion, the power to ignore ACIP.
The rest of the document is a set of arguments that are familiar to anyone dealing with anti-vaccine activists, but don’t work when the decision-maker is the government. The MAHA institute tries to present the decision as “capture” (raising a conspiracy theory) and “suppressing dissent” – but that’s not the issue.
Agency decisions cannot be based solely on dissenting from the scientific consensus (and the evidence). It actually has to be explained based on the data; the Secretary did not do that. And it is not capture to sue and demand government explain itself.
Nor, whatever the MAHA institute believes, is it a show of “regulatory integrity” to decide without deliberation, without providing the full evidentiary basis of the decision, without addressing the evidence in full. Looking at the camera in a Twitter/X video is not a substitute for a full explanation by the agency, and does not, by itself, show integrity.
Conclusion
The biggest challenge to this lawsuit is showing standing, and the lawyers did a careful, thorough job in creating a case that the people in the lawsuit have interests that are directly affected by Secretary Kennedy’s decision. If there is standing, Secretary Kennedy’s short, incomplete, and often flawed explanations will have trouble meeting the standard of explanation required from agencies, and his circumvention of ACIP will likely also run into issues.
The MAHA Institute’s attempt to respond to the lawsuit did not actually grapple with these issues, and the arguments they did make were often simply incorrect on the facts and the law, with a wink to conspiracy theories (big “they”) that does not work as well when the decision was made by the government – one of the big “they”s conspiracy theorists like to attack.
Discover more from Skeptical Raptor
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
