Skip to content
Home » RFK Jr thinks the mumps vaccine is ineffective — wrong again

RFK Jr thinks the mumps vaccine is ineffective — wrong again


During an interview in late April 2025, HHS Secretary and anti-vaxxer Robert F Kennedy Jr claimed that the “mumps part” of the MMR vaccine (for measles, mumps, and rubella) “has never worked.” Of course, he did.

Kennedy is trying to do everything he can to make people think that vaccines are either unsafe or ineffective. His attack on the mumps vaccine is just a part of his fixed and immutable beliefs that any vaccine is harmful, despite the huge amount of scientific evidence that they are safe.

This post will examine RFK Jr’s claims about the “mumps part” of the MMR vaccine and then discuss why his claims don’t hold water.

mumps vaccine
By Photo Credit: CDC/NIP/Barbara Rice – This media comes from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s Public Health Image Library (PHIL)

Mumps and the mumps vaccine

I still find it incredible that many people believe that mumps is a minor disease. Part of that is because the last major outbreak of mumps amongst children was in 1967, when over 162,000 children were infected, something we don’t see anymore.

The mumps virus causes the mumps. The disease itself is known for the swelling of the cheeks and upper chin due to the swelling of the salivary glands. Although most individuals who catch the disease recover after 1-2 weeks, the disease can cause some serious complications:

  • The most common complication is inflammation of the testicles (orchitis) in males who have reached puberty; rarely does this lead to fertility problems. However, recent epidemiological research has shown that males who are unvaccinated against mumps have a small but significantly increased risk for infertility.
  • Inflammation of the brain and/or tissue covering the brain and spinal cord (encephalitis/meningitis).
  • Inflammation of the ovaries (oophoritis) and/or breasts (mastitis) in females who have reached puberty.
  • Deafness.

Yes, these complications are rare, generally less than 5%. But if we go back to the time when over 162,000 children were infected by mumps every year (or approximately 270,000 to adjust for today’s USA population), a 5% complication rate would mean around 13,000 children would require additional treatment.

Anti-vaccine activists always seem to dismiss the risks of complications because they live in a world where the mumps vaccine has effectively reduced the incidence of the disease to a few hundred each year, evidence that the mumps vaccine does indeed work.

Mumps can only be prevented with the mumps component of the MMR vaccine, which prevents mumps, measles, and rubella. There are no miracle supplements that can prevent or lessen the severity of mumps.

The mumps vaccine was first licensed in 1967 and then approved as the combination MMR vaccine in 1971. An updated version of the MMR vaccine that offered improved protection against rubella was approved in 1978.

mumps vaccine

RFK Jr and mumps vaccine

Kennedy’s beliefs seem to rely upon a whistleblower lawsuit that claimed that Merck falsified data about the mumps component of the MMR vaccine. The lawsuit was ultimately dismissed, but Kennedy claims that it was “thrown out on a technicality, but we learned a lot about the vaccine that is disturbing.”

According to Dorit Rubinstein Reiss, PhD, UC Law San Francisco, the original whistleblower case was thrown out because the Federal government was well aware of the effectiveness of the mumps vaccine. The whistleblowers, former Merck virologists who studied the vaccine’s effectiveness, alleged that their team used techniques to make sure that the vaccine met the 95% effectiveness claimed on the product’s labelling.

But none of this is a secret. Scientists have known that the mumps vaccine has reduced effectiveness along with waning immunity. Vaccine and infectious disease experts have long acknowledged that the mumps part of the MMR vaccine was not as good as the measles and rubella parts. But that does not mean the effectiveness is 0%, despite the claims of anti-vaccine activists.

In fact, the effectiveness of mumps vaccines ranged from 72.8% to 91% for the Jeryl Lynn strain and from 91% to 94.6% after 2 doses, with waning immunity and inadequate vaccine coverage causing most outbreaks. New research shows that a third dose of the vaccine might increase the effectiveness.

Unlike the near-eradication of measles in 2000 and rubella in 2004, mumps outbreaks continue to happen in the USA and other countries. However, in a testament to the effectiveness of the mumps vaccine, the incidence of mumps cases has dropped by over 99% since the vaccine was first introduced in 1967. According to CDC data, measles cases decreased from 152,209 in 1968 to 357 in 2024.

No, the drop in cases wasn’t a result of better food, water, or whatever other claims that are out there — it was because of the vaccine.

black smartphone on white and red book
Photo by Tara Winstead on Pexels.com

Summary

Despite Kennedy’s claims about the effectiveness of the mumps vaccine, it is still a very good vaccine. No vaccine is 100% effective, and it appears that the mumps vaccine does have lower effectiveness than the other components of the MMR vaccine. But that does not mean it’s 0%, it’s still quite high. Moreover, the CDC says vaccinated individuals have less severe mumps cases.

It appears that Kennedy adheres to the Nirvana fallacy — if the vaccine is not 100% effective, it must be worthless. Of course, he believes no vaccine is useful, so if it isn’t perfect in his mind, it must not work at all.

This is just another attempt at creating doubts about vaccines, using the bully pulpit of the HHS Secretary. Since he cannot outright ban vaccines (at least, I hope he can’t), creating fear, uncertainty, and doubt about the safety and effectiveness of vaccines will help him meet his goals of making American children sick again.

The mumps component of the MMR vaccine is safe. It is also mostly effective, though scientists are working to make it more effective. Maybe it’s a simple as recommending a third dose of the MMR vaccine, but with Kennedy in charge of our health care, that may not happen.

Here is my simple conclusion — once again, ignore anything Kennedy says about vaccines, it is probably wrong.

Citations

Help the Skeptical Raptor keep writing RFK Jr and vaccines

There are four ways you can help contribute to keeping this website running at full speed:

  1. GoFundMe.
  2. Contributing via Patreon.
  3. Buying on Amazon.
  4. Sharing this article on Social Media.

Don’t miss each new article!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Liked it? Take a second to support Michael Simpson on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!


Discover more from Skeptical Raptor

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Discover more from Skeptical Raptor

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading